Divorce Spouses – Legal Services and Advice Cape Town South Africa Posted on 11 February 2025 by TelelawDivorce Spouses – Legal Services and Advice Cape Town South Africa
Claiming Child Maintenance from Grandparents – What does the law say? Many people are of the view that child maintenance may only be claimed by the parents of a child. They have that view even in the case where the parents cannot afford to maintain the child, but the grandparents can. At the outset, we state that the latter view is incorrect. If parents cannot afford to maintain a child, a claim for maintenance may be made against both the paternal and maternal grandparents of the child involved. This applies whether or not the child was born in or out of wedlock. Prior to 2004, or before the case of Petersen v Maintenance Officer, Simon’s Town Maintenance Court, and Others 2004 (2) SA 56 (C), the law allowed parents to claim maintenance for their minor children from maternal and paternal grandparents, as long as the child was born within wedlock, or out of a marriage. If the child was born out of wedlock, then in such a case, the parent could only claim from the maternal grandparents. And not the paternal grandparents. This was clearly unfair and unconstitutional and something that many people would have issues with. In 2004, Adv. Muhammad Abduroaf had a client who wanted to claim maintenance from the maternal grandparents of her minor child, but the law did not allow for it. He and his client was not happy with the legal position and took the matter to the Western Cape High Court (the Provisional Division of the Cape). Adv. Abduroaf cited the Maintenance Office of Simon’s Town Maintenance Court and the paternal grandparents. The matter was argued, and the Court found in favour of Adv. Muhammad Abduroaf and his client. The case opened many doors for mothers in similar positions. Below we discuss the case. Due to Adv. Muhammad Abduroaf’s academic background in Constitutional law and willingness to fight for his client, he challenged the legal position.Petersen v Maintenance Officer, Simon’s Town Maintenance Court, and Others2004 (2) SA 56 (C) The well-known case of Petersen v Maintenance Officer, Simon’s Town Maintenance Court, and Others 2004 (2) SA 56 (C) was a special one. Not because Adv. Abduroaf and his client were successful, but the effect of the case meant that children who could never claim maintenance from paternal grandparents if they were born out of wedlock could do so due to the case. The case also brought about widespread attention to the fact that a parent can claim maintenance from grandparents when the parents cannot afford to support the child on their own.The following is extracted from the case of Petersen v Maintenance Officer, Simon’s Town Maintenance Court, and Others 2004 (2) SA 56 (C) : [6] The Motan decision is generally accepted as authority for the assertion that the paternal grandparents of an extramarital child do not owe a duty of support to the child. The interpretation of the common law in Motan and the resultant denial of a duty of support by the paternal grandparents of an E extra-marital child has, even prior to the present constitutional dispensation, been widely criticised by South African writers. Van den Heever Breach of Promise and Seduction in South African Law (1954) at 70 says the following: ‘It is submitted that the decision is so patently wrong that it should be reconsidered; for it is based on legislative considerations and methods, which are, moreover, unsound. It is contrary to public policy and humanity and should, if necessary, be rectified by the Legislature.’This is what Adv. Abduroaf argued: [7] Mr Abduroaf, who appears for the applicant, submitted that the common-law rule as interpreted in Motan, violates the extra-marital child’s constitutional rights to equality and dignity enshrined in ss 9 and 10 of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa Act 108 of 1996 (the Constitution) and is contrary to the best interest of the child (see s 28(2) of the Constitution). He accordingly submits that the common-law rule is unreasonable and unjustifiable and should be declared unconstitutional and invalid. Adv. Abduroaf further submitted: [14] Mr Abduroaf submitted that the constitutional values embodied in ss 9, 10 and 28(2) of the Constitution, dictate that the common-law rule as enunciated in Motan, be developed by imposing a duty of support upon the paternal grandparents of an extra-marital child in the event of the natural parents of such child being unable to support the child. The said sections of the Constitution provide: ‘9 (1) Everyone is equal before the law and has the right to equal protection and benefit of the law. (2) Equality includes the full and equal enjoyment of all rights and freedoms. To promote the achievement of equality, legislative and other measures designed to protect or advance persons, or categories of persons, disadvantaged by unfair discrimination may be taken. (3) The State may not unfairly discriminate directly or indirectly against anyone on one or more grounds, including race, gender, sex, pregnancy, marital status, ethnic or social origin, colour, sexual orientation, age, disability, religion, conscience, belief, culture, language and birth. (4) No person may unfairly discriminate directly or indirectly against anyone on one or more grounds in terms of ss (3). National legislation must be enacted to prevent or prohibit unfair discrimination. (5) Discrimination on one or more of the grounds listed in ss (3) is unfair unless it is established that the discrimination is fair. 10 Everyone has inherent dignity and the right to have their dignity respected and protected. . . . 28 (2) A child’s best interest is of paramount importance in every matter concerning the child.’ The Ruling in Petersen v Maintenance Officer, Simon’s Town Maintenance Court, and Others 2004 (2) SA 56 (C) At the end of the matter, the Court made the following ruling: [29] In the result I make the following order:It is declared that the second and third respondents have a legal duty to support the extra-marital child of the applicant, J, born on 7 January 2003, to the same extent to which the fourth and fifth respondents are liable to maintain the said child.The first respondent is directed to take the necessary steps for an enquiry to be held in terms of s 10 of the Maintenance Act 99 of 1998, with a view to enquiring into the provision of maintenance by the second and third respondents for the said extra-marital child of the applicant.No order as to costs is made. Petersen v Maintenance Officer, Simon’s Town Maintenance Court, and Others 2004 (2) SA 56 (C) [caption id="attachment_10745" align="alignnone" width="300"] Adv. Muhammad Abduroaf[/caption] Posted on 11 February 2025 by Telelaw
Relocation minor child South Africa Advocate Abduroaf United States of America Los Angeles Posted on 11 February 2025 by Telelaw
Tax and UIF Frequently Asked Questions Do you have question regarding Tax and UIF? Feel free to post your questions below. What follows are samples questions that you might have in relation to your tax and UIF affairs.Can you file your taxes on your own? How do I get a tax number from SARS? How can I prepare my tax return? How do you know what your tax return will be? How do you do your taxes for free? Can I file my taxes online? Is it safe to do your taxes online? Where can you get tax forms? What you need to do your taxes? How long does it take for you to do your taxes? How do you pay income tax if you are self employed? What is a person who does taxes called? How do I get a tax number from SARS? How can I prepare my tax return? How do you know what your tax return will be? How much should I earn to submit a tax return? Is SARS open on weekends? How much do you need to earn to pay tax in South Africa? What do you need to take to SARS? What does the tax number look like? What is a tax number? How do I register for e-filing? What is the use of SARS E-filing? What is the tax reference number? How many numbers are in a tax number? Is SARS call Centre number toll free? What is meant by provisional tax? How do you know what your tax return will be? How long will it take me to do my taxes? What you can claim on your taxes? What are the documents required to file income tax return? Can you file your taxes on your own? How do I get a tax number from SARS? How can I prepare my tax return? How do you know what your tax return will be? What is your taxable income? How do you calculate tax? How long does it take to get your tax refund? How do you figure out your taxable income? How do I get my tax return? How does a tax right off work? What is the income tax percentage? What is an income tax refund? How much is tax on income? What is the income tax? What are the tax rates for 2018? How do you calculate the tax rate? How much is tax when you buy something? What percentage of your income goes to taxes? How do you figure out the tax on a total? How much does the average South African pay in taxes every year? How much is the tax on food? How do you figure out property tax? How do you take taxes out of your paycheck? How do you do a 20% tip? How do I collect my tax return? What is the difference between a tax return and a tax refund? How do you owe taxes? Can I get tax refund in South Africa? How can I get a copy of my taxes? Do you get your money back from taxes? How far can you go back on your taxes? What is the meaning of income tax refund? How do you know what your tax return will be? How do you file your tax return? How much tax do you pay if you earn R10000 a month? How much does it cost to file taxes with SARS? How do you calculate tax? What is your taxable income? Can I file my 2015 taxes in 2018? Does SARS owe me money? Why do you get a tax refund? How long does it take to get your tax refund? What is it called when you get your tax money back? How many years do you have to file a tax return? How long does it take to get your tax refund in the bank? How long does it take to get your tax refund direct deposit? What is the tax return? What is the estimated tax payment? What is the meaning of tax threshold? What is a SARS tax return? How many days will take for SARS to refund? What is a payroll withholding tax? How do we calculate taxable income? How much money do you have to make before you have to pay taxes? Can you go to jail for not filing a tax return? How long can you go without filing a tax return? What happens if you forget to file taxes? How far can SARS go back on unfiled tax returns? How do I get my tax return? How does a tax refund work? How do you do tax deductions? How can I get a copy of my taxes? How do you know what tax bracket you re in? How do you calculate the tax rate? How do you calculate tax? What is your taxable income? What is taxable income and how is it determined? What is not taxable income? What is an example of an income? Is taxable income and net income the same thing? How salary is taxed in South Africa? What is the taxable income on the income statement? How do you calculate UIF? How much should I earn to submit a tax return? How much tax do you pay for PAYE? How do I calculate my hourly rate from my salary in South Africa? How much do you need to earn before paying tax? How much salary we have to pay income tax? When you have to pay tax? How long does it take to get your UIF money? How much money do you have to make before you have to pay taxes? What is the current tax year in South Africa? What percentage of salary is UIF? How do you figure out your taxable income? What is the maximum amount that can be deducted for UIF? How much money do you get from unemployment? How do you calculate your unemployment benefits? Can you get UIF if you resign? How do you know how much you will get for unemployment? How much does UIF pay out on maternity leave? What do I need to apply for UIF? How do you register as a work seeker? How long after retrenchment can I claim UIF? Can you claim unemployment if you abscond? Can you claim UIF if you go on pension? How do I pay UIF for my domestic worker? When can you claim UIF in South Africa? How do you figure out your severance pay? What is a reasonable severance package? How do you calculate severance package? How do they calculate severance pay? How much tax is deducted from severance pay? How much do you get in a severance package? How is a lump sum severance payment taxed? How is a severance package paid out? Can you negotiate a severance agreement? What do you get in a severance package? Are severance payments taxable income? When an employee is terminated? Is a severance package required by law? What is the statutory redundancy pay? Do you get a severance package if you get laid off? What is a tax preparer called? What you need to do your taxes? How do you pay income tax if you are self employed? How do you benefit from the taxes you pay? What is a tax return? Can you file your taxes online? How do u start your own tax service business? Can you use an auditor to file for previous years of tax? Posted on 11 February 2025 by Telelaw
Adv. Muhammad Abduroaf[/caption]